Aquaponics vs Hydroponics: The Battle of Sustainable Farming Techniques

As an indoor gardening hobbyist, I’m constantly exploring and learning about innovative methods of gardening. Aquaponics and hydroponics are two such methods that have grabbed my attention. Let’s take a deeper dive into each of them and discover the differences between Aquaponics vs Hydroponics.

What is Hydroponics?

In a previous discussion, we embarked on an enlightening journey through the innovative world of hydroponics.

Hydroponics: A Definition

The usual image of plants with roots anchored in soil is transformed entirely in hydroponics. Instead of soil, we have water taking center stage as the life-bringing nutrients for plants. Hydroponics, stemming from the Greek words “hydro” (water) and “ponos” (labor), presents a clever twist to conventional gardening. It’s essentially an ingenious approach where you’re not just growing plants, but you’re nurturing them, in water.

The Hydroponic Process

The real magic happens when the soil is replaced by an inert growing medium, like perlite or vermiculite, while a nutrient-rich solution is served up directly to the plants. This method enables the plants to get direct access to all the nutrients they crave, without having to send their roots on an exploratory journey through soil. As a result, they grow faster and bigger because they can invest all their energy into leaf and fruit production instead of extensive root systems. It’s a bit like giving your plants a pass to a buffet of all their favorite nutrients.

The Benefits of Hydroponics

Taking a page from our past post, hydroponics offers complete control over the plant’s environment. You control the nutrient levels, lighting, and temperature to create the perfect opportunity for growth. The precision and control that hydroponics offers are why this method is highly favored for indoor and urban gardening, especially when space and soil quality are limiting factors.

Hydroponics is not just a soil-less plant cultivation method, it’s a paradigm shift in the way we approach indoor gardening. It’s a testament to human ingenuity, harnessing the power of water to create a high-yield, space-efficient, and environmentally friendly gardening solution.

What is Aquaponics?

aquaponicsAquaponics is a unique, eco-friendly method of indoor gardening that combines aquaculture (raising aquatic animals) and hydroponics (growing plants in water). The fish waste acts as a natural fertilizer for the plants, and in return, the plants purify the water for the fish.

The Magic of Aquaponics

The secret sauce of aquaponics lies in its brilliant use of nature’s own recycling system. The fish in the system produce waste, as all living creatures do. But here’s where the magic happens: instead of this waste becoming a problem, it becomes a solution. This waste, rich in nutrients, serves as an organic food source for the plants.

Benefiting from the Cycle

These nutrients are something of a gourmet meal for plants. And just like we thrive when we have a good meal, so do the plants. They grow stronger, healthier, and often faster than they would in traditional soil-based systems. But the plants aren’t the only ones who benefit from this system. The process of absorbing these nutrients also purifies the water, which is then recirculated back to the fish tank. This forms a symbiotic relationship between the fish and the plants, each helping the other to survive and thrive.

Embracing Sustainable Farming

In essence, aquaponics is a highly sustainable form of farming that mimics the natural waterways of our world. It’s an ecosystem in a box, right there in your home or backyard. It’s a way to grow fresh, organic produce and fish in a system that benefits both the environment and your palate.

So, there you have it, the essence of aquaponics. A system that might sound complicated at first, but is ultimately a simple, efficient, and sustainable way of farming.  Isn’t that something worth exploring?

Key DifferencesThe Key Differences Between Aquaponics and Hydroponics

While both aquaponics and hydroponics share the characteristic of soil-less growing, the journey they take to arrive at the final, thriving plant is quite distinct. These differences are crucial, shaping the way you manage your indoor garden and the nature of the produce you grow.

System Composition

First, let’s look at the composition of these systems. Hydroponics uses a mineral nutrient solution to feed the plants, a sort of liquid lunch that the plants absorb directly from the water. The gardener manually adds this mixture to the water, carefully controlling the pH and nutrient balance to create an optimal growing environment. This level of control is the essence of hydroponics, like having the reins of the plant growth in your hands.

On the other hand, aquaponics introduces a biological element into the mix – fish! In this system, it’s the fish that supply the nutrients through their waste. The bacteria in the system convert this waste into nitrates, a form that the plants can absorb. This turns the process into a symbiotic cycle where the plants purify the water for the fish, and the fish provide the nutrients for the plants. It’s like a miniature, self-sustaining ecosystem right at home.

System Management

The second key difference lies in the management of these systems. In hydroponics, the gardener must closely monitor the nutrient levels and pH of the solution, requiring frequent testing and adjustments. This ensures the plants get the right balance of nutrients for optimal growth.

Conversely, an aquaponics system needs the gardener to monitor both the health of the fish and the plants. It’s a balance that might take a bit of practice to perfect, but when done right, it provides a holistic approach to indoor gardening that supports both plant and aquatic life.

Personal Goals and Preferences

Finally, the choice between hydroponics and aquaponics often comes down to your personal goals and preferences. If you seek complete control over the growing conditions and prefer a more hands-on approach, hydroponics might be your system of choice. If sustainability and creating a balanced ecosystem align with your gardening ethos, aquaponics will be your go-to method.

In the end, whether you choose hydroponics or aquaponics, you’ll be participating in a revolutionary method of gardening that’s not only efficient and productive but also a whole lot of fun.

Pros and Cons of Aquaponics

As we dive deeper into the world of aquaponics, it’s essential to have a well-rounded view. Like any farming technique, aquaponics has its fair share of pros and cons, which can influence your decision depending on your specific needs and circumstances.

Pros of Aquaponics


One of the most significant advantages of aquaponics is its sustainability. It’s a closed-loop system that uses less water than traditional farming methods because the water is recycled within the system. Additionally, it eliminates the need for chemical fertilizers, which can harm the environment. Instead, the plants benefit from the natural waste produced by the fish.

Dual Yield

Another exciting advantage of aquaponics is the dual yield. Not only are you growing plants, but you’re also raising fish. This gives you the unique advantage of producing both a protein source and fresh greens right in your backyard or home.

Soilless Gardening

Aquaponics provides the benefits of soilless gardening, such as faster plant growth and a reduced risk of soil-borne diseases. The nutrients are delivered directly to the plants’ roots, allowing them to focus their energy on growing above ground, which typically results in larger, healthier plants.

Cons of Aquaponics

System Complexity

On the flip side, setting up an aquaponics system can be complex. Unlike traditional gardening, it requires a certain level of knowledge and expertise to correctly balance the needs of both the fish and the plants. This may not be an ideal method for beginner gardeners.

Initial Cost

While aquaponics can be cost-effective over time due to its high yield and sustainability, the initial setup cost can be high. Purchasing the necessary equipment and setting up the system can be an investment.

Limitations on Plant Types

While many plants thrive in an aquaponics system, not all can be grown effectively. Root vegetables, for instance, can be challenging to grow in aquaponics systems.

In conclusion, aquaponics is a rewarding and sustainable method of indoor gardening with its own set of advantages and challenges. If the prospect of creating a balanced ecosystem excites you and you’re ready to tackle the initial learning curve and setup costs, aquaponics can be a fascinating and fruitful adventure in your gardening journey.

Pros and Cons of Hydroponics

Just like aquaponics, hydroponics has its unique strengths and drawbacks, which is covered in a previous post.

DecidingDeciding Between Aquaponics and Hydroponics

Once you’ve explored the intricacies of both aquaponics and hydroponics, you might find yourself standing at a crossroads. Both methods have unique benefits and challenges, and the choice isn’t always easy. But fear not, this decision can be made easier by taking into account a few key considerations.

Your Gardening Goals

First, let’s reflect on your personal goals. Are you primarily focused on the yield, looking for the quickest and most abundant harvest possible? Or is sustainability, creating a balanced ecosystem, your main goal? If you’re more inclined towards the former, hydroponics with its precise nutrient control might be the way to go. However, if you’re fascinated by the idea of a self-sustaining miniature ecosystem, then aquaponics would be an excellent fit.

The Time and Effort You’re Willing to Invest

Next, consider the time and effort you’re ready to invest in your indoor garden. Both systems require attention and care, but in different ways. Hydroponics demands meticulous monitoring and adjustment of nutrient levels, pH, and light. On the other hand, aquaponics requires a delicate balance between the health of your aquatic life and your plants. This can be a challenging but rewarding process, akin to nurturing a complete ecosystem.

Initial Investment and Long-Term Costs

Cost is another factor to take into account. The initial investment for both systems can be significant, considering the equipment and setup costs. However, in the long run, aquaponics may turn out to be more cost-effective as it doesn’t require continual purchase of nutrient solutions. It’s crucial to consider both your initial budget and your willingness to bear ongoing costs.

Variety of Produce

Lastly, consider the variety of produce you want to grow. While hydroponics allows you to grow almost any type of plant with the right nutrient mix, aquaponics may be more suited for leafy greens and herbs, due to the nutrient composition. However, if you’re excited by the idea of raising fish alongside your vegetables, then aquaponics brings an added bonus.

In the end, the choice between aquaponics and hydroponics depends on your personal preferences, goals, and resources. It’s about finding the balance that works for you in your indoor gardening journey. Whether you lean towards the biological harmony of aquaponics or the nutrient precision of hydroponics, both offer an exciting, fruitful, and rewarding venture into the world of soil-less farming.

Recommended Systems to Get Started

If you are now interested in trying out one of these methods of indoor gardening, but don’t know where to start, here are some recommended systems to help you begin your journey in either aquaponics and hydroponics:

Recommended SystemAquaponics Starter Kit – AquaSprouts Garden Aquaponics System

The AquaSprouts Garden Aquaponics System is an excellent option for newbies. It has a modern and unique design, combining aquaculture and hydroponics. This system converts a regular 10 gallon aquarium into a functional aquaponic system. The AquaSprouts Garden is a self-contained ecosystem with a mechanism that connects an aquarium at the base to the grow bed on top via a pump. The waste products from the fish in the aquarium fertilize the plants in the grow bed, which is a mixture of clay pebbles and tank water, and the water is then re-circulated back into the tank. Key features include:

  • Grow Bed: It can be easily installed on top of the aquarium and can grow different types of plants ranging from herbs, vegetables, and even fruits. It comes with adjustable risers to change the level or depth of the grow bed depending on the type of plants you are growing.
  • Light Bar: If your setup does not get sufficient natural light, you can install the hanging light bar on top of the garden, and adjust its height depending on your plants.
  • Timer and Pump: The pump serves the purpose of pumping the water upwards to the garden where the waste from the fishes break down into pure nitrates, which in turn fertilizes the plants. The timer is connected to the pump, regulating the flow of water and reducing the need for frequent cleaning.
  • Clay Pebbles: These act as the growing medium for the plants to get nutrients. They also help in breaking down harmful ammonia in the aquarium into nitrates, making the environment safe for the fishes.

Recommended SystemHydroponics Starter Kit- AeroGarden Harvest Elite

If hydroponics seems more up your alley, consider a system like the AeroGarden Harvest Elite that I’ve mentioned before. It is a compact, beautifully designed system that comes with LED lights and seed pods, making it a breeze for newbies to set up and grow plants all year round.

Remember, starting off with the right system can make your journey into aquaponics or hydroponics much smoother. Consider the space you have, the level of commitment you can give, and the types of plants you want to grow before making a choice. Happy gardening!


In the battle of aquaponics vs hydroponics, it’s not about which method is superior. Instead, it’s about which system best suits your individual needs and indoor gardening goals. Now, isn’t it fascinating how much control we can have over growing our own food indoors?


Q1. Is it easier to start with aquaponics or hydroponics?

While hydroponics systems can be simpler to set up initially, they do require more frequent maintenance. Aquaponics systems, while more complex, often require less daily upkeep.

Q2. Can I switch between aquaponics and hydroponics?

Yes, many components of these systems can be interchanged. However, switching would require adjustments to accommodate the different nutrient delivery methods.

Q3. What crops can I grow with these systems?

Both systems can support a wide variety of crops, including leafy greens, herbs, and even some fruits. However, root vegetables may not fare well due to their growth habits.

Q4. Is one system more eco-friendly than the other?

Aquaponics is generally considered more eco-friendly due to its closed-loop system, which minimizes water and nutrient waste.

Q5. Can these systems be used for commercial production?

Yes, both systems have been successfully used for commercial farming. They are particularly popular in urban settings where space is limited.

Avatar photo

Jim Allred

Raised on a farm and now thriving in the city, I'm a passionate advocate for hydroponics and indoor gardening. With a background rooted in traditional farming and an eye on the future of sustainable agriculture, I bring a unique perspective to urban gardening. Through this website, I aim to share my knowledge and experiences, hoping to inspire and educate others on the potential of hydroponics. Together, we'll explore how we can bring the garden into our homes and the future of farming into our present. Let's grow together!

More to Explore